Sign in to wikis by wetpaint

Sign in or

Location: American Idol Discussion Forum

Discussion: The Top 6 take on the songs of Carole King

Category: Discussion Forum / American Idol Season 10

Report thread
Watch thread
Share this

Showing 5 posts

ChillyMe	The Top 6 take on the songs of Carole King Apr 27 2011, 11:09 PM EDT Yep, they did and did it well. My favorite and Randy's favorite of the night was James Durbin. It is my hope to see James and Casey in the finale. They are both strong performers, consistently good and are always getting praised. More power to them. Thoughts? Share them here! :) Post reply Do you find this valuable? Keyword tags: None
chrisco97	1. RE: The Top 6 take on the songs of Carole King Apr 28 2011, 3:35 PM EDT James and Lauren were my favourites last night. James showed he has singing talent, and Lauren showed she can sing to the crowd and have stage presence. They were both amazing last night. My least favourites of the night was Casey and Haley. Both were HORRIBLE. -- My favourite Duet was James and Jacob. They both flowed well together. My least favourite duet was Casey and Haley. More HORRIBLE. -- I see Casey, Haley, and Scotty in the bottom three. With Casey or Haley leaving. Post reply Do you find this valuable?
ChillyMe	2. RE: The Top 6 take on the songs of Carole King Apr 28 2011, 9:35 PM EDT Casey picked the wrong song for sure, as he is now going home. Casey is one of my favorites, but even I admit to not liking his performance last night. I'm still shocked he was sent home. I thought for sure, FOR SURE that Jacob would be going home with Haley as a close second. Oh well. I will now support James 100% and hope he wins!! I hate country music, so Scotty's never been my favorite. Lauren could pass for contemporary, so she's alright. No Jacob or Haley either. James all the way!! Post reply Do you find this valuable?
ChillyMe	3. RE: The Top 6 take on the songs of Carole King Apr 28 2011, 10:04 PM EDT Casey Abrams, you're so multi-talented and genuine! You shouldn't have been sent home. Many in the South couldn't vote due to storms and maybe that had something to do with it. You will be missed. Best wishes to you in future endeavors. You'll be alright. Post reply Do you find this valuable?
PeggySoule	4. RE: The Top 6 take on the songs of Carole King May 2 2011, 2:26 AM EDT \| Post edited: May 2 2011, 2:26 AM EDT "Yep, they did and did it well. My favorite and Randy's favorite of the night was James Durbin. It is my hope to see James and Casey in the finale. They are both strong performers, consistently good and are always getting praised. More power to them. Thoughts? Share them here! :)" James is by far the best. I love the way he changes up his style and still makes it incredible. Casey had turned to all jazz and if you liked jazz it was ok, but i really don't like it. I llike Scotty but wonder if he can only sing country. Lauren has a lot of power, but none of them are in James equal. Post reply Do you find this valuable?